Something that I’ve always been fascinated by is the rhetoric in travel blogging around the ability to travel, and the financial discussions and implications of traveling for a living. Most bloggers, from my experience, have defended their lifestyle as something that anyone can attain, no matter their current means or socioeconomic status. The common thread is the thought that if one works hard and saves the best they can, then they too can quit their job (or jobs) and become “location independent.” I see article after article (ok, blog post after blog post) about bloggers sick of answering questions about how they can afford to travel – and other than a few honest posts here and there, I don’t see many bloggers actually answering the question directly.
I think it’s because no one likes to talk about privilege.
Travel is an extreme privilege, and it’s because of shame of that privilege that most bloggers refuse to acknowledge that actually, no, most people cannot upend their lives to become digital nomads. There are already too damn many travel blogs out there to fill any given niche to economically support that many people traveling the world and finding themselves. Some folks just have to find themselves at home.
This is why travel bloggers get angry when people ask them how they can afford to travel the world without having a job, or without thinking of other responsibilities.
Humans are, for whatever reason, uncomfortable when confronted by those less fortunate than themselves. It is a base instinct to try and place oneself on equal footing with those around them – so when encountered with questions about affordability, it is typically easier to shrug off the question by saying that anyone could do it than to actually say, “Well, X, Y, and Z fortunate circumstances in my life allowed me to do this.” Personally, I am thankful to be without student debt, to have a job that affords me the opportunity to take exotic (though frugal) trips with my husband, and to not have any dependents I need to support. These are the factors which allow me to travel. Not to mention, I am privileged to have been raised speaking English, the world’s first language (for the time being), and to be a white male, arguably the sole demographic that can travel with relative ease almost anywhere in the world. Being gay doesn’t do me any favors, so I’ll leave that one off the table for now.
And being able to travel the world (full time or not) is a privilege. Any traveler, digital nomad, or whatever you want to call it has enough capital to pay for that first plane ticket or book that hostel room. They are not bound by any type of obligation to stay home, earn money immediately, pay debts, etc. (I understand that many folks travel and pay student loans simultaneously, but that is a rarity). To make money while traveling the world takes time and work and talent, sure, but it also takes a certain amount of serendipity that doesn’t fall to anyone that wants it, and it’s incredibly naive to think that’s true.
I don’t mean to come off as bitter. I have no doubt that if I really wanted to, I could live on the road and make a decent living. That’s not what I have chosen for myself and my family – instead I have chosen relative financial security so that my family can afford to travel more permanently in the future, when hopefully we can not worry about working at the same time. This prospective situation is one that I’ll only be able to manage if I am equal parts diligent and lucky. But also one that I wouldn’t be able to achieve with a whole lot of privilege in a world that, for whatever reason, has dealt me a good set of cards.
Shrugging off privilege is easy and convenient. No one wants to think they have it better off than anyone else – or that they have better or different opportunities that allow them more myriad travel opportunities. But it’s also irresponsible.
As people producing content that’s meant to be useful and unbiased, we’re responsible for creating accurate information, and misconstruing our personal experiences doesn’t help the reader planning a trip to whatever destination they’re reading about. Let’s be open about our privileges, innate and acquired, and stop perpetuating the narrative that anyone can lead a vagabond life, gallivanting around the world. In a perfect world this would be true, but unfortunately it’s just not the case.
7 comments
I seriously couldn’t agree with you more. I am white, American, and came from a pretty stable background. I have an MBA and am well-educated. Yes, I’ve worked hard, but let’s be honest, the cards were kind of dealt in my favor. I mean that in the humblest of ways.
I hate reading shit (yes, it is shit) from other bloggers about “Don’t call me lucky because I’ve worked so hard for all of this”… because they are lucky to have been brought into a society that granted them a passport allowing them to do this shit in the first place. They grew up in a society that allowed them to receive a good education and not have to start working to support their family at age 14. Etc, etc, etc.
I’m all about inspiring people to do what they love, but you’ll NEVER hear me say anyone should travel the world full-time or spend all of their money traveling. It isn’t for everyone, even if their passport and upbringing allows them to do it easily.
When I was in Kazakhstan, it was really evident to me the privilege I grew up with in the oddest of fashions. Many well-educated Kazakhs will do an exchange in the US for a few years (they have a special working holiday program w/ the US), but obviously most can’t afford it, despite being the most affluent country in central Asia. When I was in Astana, I took a train to Karaganda with a female who spoke no English, but still wanted to try to converse. We found someone on the same train to interpret English to Russian and we were able to chat. Somehow, she saw my passport peeking out of my bag and was intrigued (I usually keep it very hidden when I travel because I don’t like talking about my travels to people in some countries because of privilege). She asked to go through it and I let her and she was in awe. Seriously was awestruck by the amount of pages and visas and stamps. She said it was her dream to travel outside of Kazakhstan (she hadn’t even been to Almaty), but females just aren’t supposed to do that there. They are supposed to get married by age 22 and that is about it. While I know everyone’s destiny is their own, you can’t really say much because their society does what their society thinks is acceptable. This is when I realized what true privilege is. While in our westernized lands we say “Oh… people want us to follow the societal norms of going to college and then straight to working”, no one really cares if you decide to be unconventional and travel or do something unusual. They may say something to you, but we are instilled with enough confidence that we can still follow our dreams without too much scrutiny. It is not the same in other parts of the world.
Yadda yadda, I’m rambling… but I definitely agree w/ this post and it struck a chord with me 🙂
i had issues commenting btw- hope the first one went through!
Couldn’t agree more. And thanks for calling a spade a spade. And by that I mean calling shit shit. The narrative of universal ability to travel really only serves to lift oneself up and shame others for not making the same decisions in life, regardless of opportunities afforded to them by socioeconomic status, race, nationality, or maybe even the flying spaghetti monster or whatever dude/lady in the sky who’s running things. It makes me sick and it takes all of my will to not engage with those people.
It’s even worse when those folks are purposefully incendiary just to get clicks. F that.
It’s funny, I have a similar story. When I was in Mongolia, I became close friends with my tour guide – a Mongolian woman. She was definitely of higher socioeconomic standing than most Mongolians, and yet, when she came to visit me in America, she was treated like a terrorist. The amount of rigmarole she was put through to get her visa first off, and then they held her at immigration for three hours despite her having a visa – likely because they hadn’t heard of Mongolia, and have been indoctrinated to fear what they don’t know like the rest of the country.
So yeah, these self important jerks who pat themselves on the back for having a ton of disposable income from mom and dad OR writing crap posts sponsored shit brands, all the while chilling in hostels with other Aussie/British/Canadian/American tourists…Ain’t nobody got time for that. At least not this guy.
Glad the post resonated with you – I knew we were of the same ilk!
This is an excellent one, Nick! It is nice to read a different point of view and I also really love the photos you chose to go along with what you’ve written.
Excellent one, Nick. It is nice to read a different and very valid point of view. I think there is another point to make too … Some friends that I’ve since lost touch with were a bit ‘upset’ that I traveled so much. Now, we had similar educations, went to similar schools, and had equally privileged middle class upbringings, yet I lived (still do) really cheaply to save for travel and they didn’t. This is where some butting-heads started, as those old friends didn’t understand this lifestyle choice. It may be that some of the other blogs posts are addressing those readers specifically, but are instead writing general posts for everyone.
Also, traveling all the time while working is exhausting! I can’t imagine that being my full-time job. Kudos to those who can make it work.
FYI. I also had problems posting my comment.
Thanks for your response, ELizabeth! You know, it’s just a pet peeve of mine. I think we all need to acknowledge what we have and how it may not be equal for everyone. I’m definitely in the same boat as you, living really cheaply at home so I can go on a couple of trips a year. I’ve never had an issue with friends and jealousy – but I think that’s mostly because many of my friends would never think to go somewhere like the Balkans on holiday. Their loss!
I understand the reasons for posts meant to inspire people to travel more, but the fact of the matter is that travel isn’t accessible for most. Either way, 90% of traffic is likely from other bloggers anyway, so it’s neither here nor there in the end. Or I’m just jaded. Ha!
Nick! I love this post! I actually prefer your type of travel though. I love to go new places, but I definitely prefer having somewhere to go home to!